Team USA Rugby Eagles Should Play In Germany, Not Wales

October 17, 201217 Comments

“Expecting a rugby match between Russia and the USA to promote rugby in North Wales is the equivalent of putting a Belarus vs. France hockey game in Mississippi and expecting it to promote hockey there.”

Team USA Rugby Eagles

COLWYN BAY, WALES – In November, the Team USA Eagles (15s) will go on a three-match tour of Europe, taking on Tonga, Russia and Romania. The match against Romania will be played in Romania, but the Tonga and Russia matches will be played in Colwyn Bay, a small town in North Wales. This leads to the obvious question: Why?

The IRB is funding the matches in North Wales and they are looking to promote rugby there, as rugby’s popularity in the Principality is mainly in the more populous South Wales. However, it’s obvious to anyone with knowledge of the situation that putting these matches in Colwyn Bay is an awful idea. Not only does it do a huge disservice to the teams involved, but people who were not previously interested in rugby are not going to be drawn to watch Tier 2 rugby teams to whom they have no allegiance. Expecting a rugby match between Russia and the USA to promote rugby in North Wales is the equivalent of putting a Belarus vs. France hockey game in Mississippi and expecting it to promote hockey there. For all of its blunders, even the IIHF (International Ice Hockey Federation) would not be so foolish.

If the Eagles are going to play other countries at a neutral site in Europe, they should be playing near US Military bases in Germany. This serves a number of purposes:

The first thing it does is put the match near people who have a reason to show up. Unless people really love rugby, they are unlikely to attend a match between two teams they have no reason to support. Germany is home to over 50,000 active duty members of the US Military, far more than any other country in Europe. These servicemen tend to be patriotic and supportive of things American. It’s a natural fan base for the Eagles to tap into – far better than that of people in North Wales with no ties to any team involved. If USA Rugby and the IRB got creative about the marketing of the event, it might even get some media coverage in the US, much like the early season basketball games on aircraft carriers have been able to attain widespread media coverage at a time of year when college basketball is usually an afterthought.

Ngwenya plays in Biarritz, France. Close to Germany.

Putting an Eagles test in Germany also serves as a testing ground for future matches there, and not just for normal tests but for potential entry into the European Nations Cup. With much of the current Eagles squad playing in Europe, it would make sense to try entering this European competition. It takes place during one of the IRB-mandated test windows and could have the Eagles  playing nations at their level. The alternative is burning out Eagle players coming off lengthy European seasons by playing all summer in the rumored new Pan-Pacific competition, which is replacing the Churchill Cup.

Further, Germany would be the ideal place for these matches because playing home matches in the USA (in such a competition) is unrealistic – due to the cost and travel. Granted, Germany would need to be tested as a base for the Eagles before committing to the European Nations Cup, but a November test, that would otherwise be played at a neutral site, is the ideal time to test this out.

Wyles plays for Saracens. Close to Germany

Lastly, hosting an Eagles test near US Military bases in Germany would strengthen the ties between USA Rugby and the US Military. American rugby has been bolstered by players from the military for years and the military academies have historically been among the best collegiate teams in the nation. With members of the military such as Will Holder, Marcus Satavu and Eric Duechle – among others- in or around the USA squads (15s and 7s), playing a test in front of their fellow servicemen would further promote those ties and foster good will.

The tests in North Wales are the IRB’s blunder, but the onus is on USA Rugby to move forward with a November test in front of our servicemen in Germany in the future.

Please feel free to weigh in below and please look for and “Like” our Facebook Rugby Wrap Up Page and follow us on Twitter @RugbyWrapUp, @michaelholzman, @JunoirBlaber, @Declan Yeats and @Mathew Drew Turner, respectively.

P.s... Please see the Counter-Rucking Cancer fundraiser. It only takes a moment and anything you have to give is appreciated. Please forward the cause to your mates.

Filed in: Mike Holzman
Tagged with:

  • http://twitter.com/JunoirBlaber Junoir Blaber

    Good Idea but the IRB helps fund USA Rugby and so it gets to call the shots!!

  • Ardent Supporter

    There has to be some reason why nobody has thought about Germany. Otherwise, your points are too obvious for the IRB not to see. I hope.

    • http://twitter.com/JunoirBlaber Junoir Blaber

      Hidden in plain sight!! It makes sense almost too much sense!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Harlem-Shaskys/100002347021401 Harlem Shaskys

    Do we really trust the Germans???

    • http://rugbywrapup.com/ RugbyWrapUp

      At a rugby match, yes. At a soccer match, no.

  • http://rugbywrapup.com/ RugbyWrapUp

    German women + German beer + International Rugby = We need a plane ticket!

  • http://twitter.com/AshTurkee Ashley Caldwell

    I can guarantee you that Parc Eirias will be sold out for all games. Wales deserves it a lot more than Germany. Let them carry on playing awful American football.

    • http://twitter.com/DeclanYeats Declan Yeats

      Or shite soccer!

    • http://meetthematts.com/ Meet The Matts

      What’s the wager, Ashley? We’ll take a piece of that action.

    • http://twitter.com/michaelholzman Mike Holzman

      This is not about who deserves it but rather the best allocation of these tests for the sport, particularly from an American perspective, going forward. I’m not really sure why North Wales would deserve to host these tests based on their poor support of rugby in the past, either. There is a reason North Wales lacks not only a RaboDirect Pro12 team, but also lacks a team in the 14 team Welsh Premier Division or the 14 team Welsh Championship, the two levels below the Pro12. North Wales had a WRU-created team in the Premier Division, but it went into liquidation within a couple years and no longer plays at that level.

  • Kenny D

    The thought is likely that Wales has more rugby tradition than the other countries – other than Tonga, perhaps, and that Germany is a futbol nation.

    • http://twitter.com/JunoirBlaber Junoir Blaber

      No, the thing is the WRU has spent money on a new facility up in North Wales and is trying to make that soccer mad area, a rugby area so they get the IRB to host internationals there and it will help the WRU. The could have give the US a match in London with some Ex-pats there at least.

  • http://twitter.com/DeclanYeats Declan Yeats

    I’ve played in Wales and never been disappointed. Is it better to play in front of less people that know the game or more that don’t?

  • http://twitter.com/ericpz PZ

    There are US Military bases in the UK just a few hours drive to North Wales. Perhaps they should move the games further East in order to make it easier for the Air Force personnel to to attend.

  • http://www.facebook.com/daryl.capen Daryl Capen

    The fact is that the US has to become better at Rugby and commit resources and finances to becoming a Rugby force in order to move up the rankings (look at the nations we’re behind). Only then will USA Rugby have a say in determining where to play some of these matches. US Rugbyis dependent on the tit of the IRB for money and support!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=578991352 Jason Gatties

    The USA Women had fantastic support during the last FIFA Women’s World Cup while in Germany. The atmosphere was like playing a home game. Great article.

  • http://www.facebook.com/pedanticpete Peter M Evans

    Too many morons in admin both in USA and IRB. We have the womens international sevens tournament here in Houston on Superbowl weekend. Are you nuts? Not only is Texas one of the main party towns during SB weekend, but there is a good chance Houston will be in final.

Back to Top