Top 14 Preview: No Respite For European Dreamers

2 Comments

Nick Abendanon is enjoying his time at Clermont

Nick Abendanon is enjoying his time at Clermont

CASTRES, FRANCE – Toulon and Clermont – and probably Racing Metro – may wish they had a week off after the intensity of last weekend’s European Champions Cup quarter finals, but the Top 14 waits for no club. It won’t even wait for the Rugby World Cup, so three of the top four clubs have no chance.

Toulon and Clermont may have one eye on next week’s European semi finals, but this week they face the small matter of holding on to the all-important top two places in the Top 14, which carry with them the bonus of a week off in the play-off phase of the season.

And with Stade Francais breathing down their necks, this weekend’s matches, cruelly sandwiched between the last-eight and last-four games in European club rugby’s leading competition, are especially important for the two French sides looking to set up a repeat of the 2013 Heineken Cup final.

Clermont have arguably the easier game of the Top 14’s top two this week. They are at home – where they annihilated Northampton last week, and where they have only lost once this season and twice in any competition since November 2009.

The Jaunards welcome sixth-place Oyonnax to the high-walled Stade Marcel Michelin, which has been described as a graveyard for visiting teams, but is more accurately a bearpit where visitors are – as the Saints learned last week – casually ripped apart while the baying crowd roars for more.

Oyonnax are punching above their weight this season, and currently hold on to the last of the six play-off places. But it is surely an almost-impossible ask for Christophe Urios’s side to claim their third Top 14 win on the road this season, at a ground where Franck Azema’s Clermont are close to unbeatable.

But, with next week’s European Champions Cup semi final against Saracens at St Etienne in their minds, maybe this week Clermont will be just a little distracted. Unlikely. But possible.

Toulon's Freddie Michalak

Toulon’s Freddie Michalak

Toulon, meanwhile, face a difficult Alpine day out on Saturday, as they head to Grenoble, who are still smarting from their surprise loss against Castres at the same ground last time out.

Bernard Laporte’s team have come off worst in two of the last three close encounters at Stade des Alpes, losing two and drawing one. They also looked far from certain against Wasps in the European quarter-final last week, so – with Leinster looming large on the Var side’s horizon – Grenoble will set a tough challenge.

Toulon have only lost twice in their last six Top 14 games – but those defeats raised big questions. The first, at Bordeaux, came after they had raced into a big first-half lead, and the second, against Toulouse in Marseille, was the second instance of the rouge-et-noir snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.

Shhh... Look who's back for Stade Francais

Shhh… Look who’s back for Stade Francais

Third-place Stade Francais will be paying close attention to the matches in Clermont and Grenoble, after opening the weekend’s Top 14 action at La Rochelle. This is a tougher match to call than it would first appear. The Rochelais may be hovering just above the relegation zone, but they still have an outside chance of mounting a late play-off challenge – and they are unbeaten in their last five Top 14 outings. It has not been an easy run, either. They have beaten Clermont, Oyonnax and Brive at home, edged the Atlantic coast derby at Bordeaux and drew at Montpellier.

La Rochelle are tough to beat at Marcel Deflandre, so don’t be surprised to see them extend their unbeaten streak to six by the end of the weekend.

Racing Metro could have hoped for easier Top 14 opponents than Montpellier as they look to recover from last week’s gut-wrenching last-gasp European Champions Cup defeat against Saracens.

The two sides’ recent Top 14 records could not be more different. The Colombes side look a Racing certainty for a place in the play-offs, while Montpellier have won only one of their last four. Their challenge for the top six – and with it a place on Europe’s top table next season – is fading fast. Unless, that is, they can spring a surprise at Stade Yves du Manoir this weekend.

Much will depend on how well Racing have recovered from last weekend’s heartbreak, but a home win is the most likely result.

Expect fireworks at Stade Amedee Domenech where 12th-place Brive entertain 14th-placed Lyon in a match that is likely to go a long way to deciding the Top 14 future of both clubs.

Times are tough at Lyon right now

Times are tough at Lyon right now

Brive have a double advantage. They’re at home, where they have only lost twice this season. And they are six points better off than their opponents, whose backs are firmly wedged against the wall following defeats in their last five outings.

Defeat may not officially herald the end of the season-long Top 14 adventure for last year’s ProD2 champions Lyon – even after this weekend, there are still up to 20 points up for grabs – but it is would make them odds-on favourites to bounce straight back down.

It goes to prove that money – even in the Top 14 – isn’t the answer. Lyon had the sixth-highest budget of any club in the French top flight this season, had signed some big names and entered the competition full of vim, vigour and ambition. The grand vision has changed at the Matmut Stadium – now their ambition is simply to survive. Whether they can is likely to depend on the result of this weekend’s clash.

Whisper it quietly. Despite a beyond-dismal season that has seen them rooted to the foot of the Top 14 for long periods, Castres are secretly daring to believe. Victory over Lyon the last time they were at home, despite being reduced to 14 men midway through the first half, was followed by a near-miss – and a potentially crucial defensive bonus point – at Bayonne. That, in turn, was followed by a win against all the odds at Grenoble that pulled them off the bottom of the table.

They’re not out of the frying pan yet – they’re still in the relegation zone and have a difficult run-in, but the faith is returning.

With Rory Kockott suspended, expect to see Cedric Garcia in Castres colours

With Rory Kockott suspended, expect to see Cedric Garcia in Castres colours

How long it lasts will depend on the results of the next two games. Both of them are at home. But both of them are against tough opposition – first Bordeaux, then Clermont.

The Girondins are the least confident right now. Ever since what are still officially just rumours surrounding head coach Raphael Ibanez’s next job reached fever pitch, Bordeaux have looked a little out of sorts. A little lost. They have lost their last three Top 14 games, and slipped out of contention for what looked a nailed-on play-off place earlier in the season.

It’s rising belief against lapsing faith. At home, rising belief surely wins.

Which could be bad news for Bayonne. They are on the road this week, at a resurgent Toulouse. If results go against them, the weekend could end with them occupying the second relegation spot.

It has been a strange season for the declining Toulouse. A five-match losing streak early on set the tone of a topsy-turvy campaign, which a European Champions Cup-led recovery that saw them on the verge of the quarter finals before Bath’s demolition job at Stade Ernest Wallon.

But four wins in their last five games, including that epic comeback against Toulon in Marseille last time out, have pulled the richest club in Europe back into the play-off places. And, belatedly, the old swagger is returning.

Which is definitely bad news for Bayonne.

Feel free to comment below, look for and “Like” our Facebook Rugby Wrap Up Page and follow us on Twitter@: RugbyWrapUp, James Harrington, Junoir Blaber, Jamie Wall, Nick Hall, DJ Eberle, Jake Frechette, Scheenagh Harrington, Jamie Loyd, Cody Kuxmann, Karen Ritter, Audrey Youn, Akweley Okine and Declan Yeats, respectively.

Share Button

Filed in: EuropeJames HarringtonTop 14
Tagged with:

About the Author ()

James Harrington... Before injury brought his rugby career to a timely end, journalist James was equally useless whether he packed down in the second row or at number 8, positions in which he represented his school and university with indistinction. The prolific one now lives in France with his journalist wife and three children and watches as much Top 14, European and international action he thinks he can get away with; justifying his obsession by claiming: "But it's all work, Honey!"

Back to Top